IMEX Malta |
IMEX Malta - It's a personal service. The Gateway to Europe. |
 | 
|
Malta Central Bank Head Edward Scicluna Suspends Himself Amid Hospitals Scandal
Last changed: July 31 2024 07:20 by PCLMedia
Edward Scicluna, the governor of Malta’s central bank, has requested to step aside from his role amid a court case concerning a 2015 hospitals privatization deal. The request was made to European Central Bank (ECB) President Christine Lagarde, according to a statement from Malta’s government.
“The cabinet of ministers recognizes that the decision taken by Professor Scicluna is in the best national interest,” the government stated on its website on Tuesday. Prime Minister Robert Abela later clarified to the media that Scicluna will retain his salary during this temporary step-down.
Terms and Transition
Prime Minister Abela emphasized that Scicluna’s employment terms "will remain the same" during his suspension. During a Cabinet meeting, a compromise was reached allowing Scicluna to step aside while maintaining his employment conditions. His responsibilities as governor will be temporarily assumed by Deputy Governor Alex Demarco.
Charges and Denials
Scicluna, 77, faces accusations of fraud and misappropriation alongside 13 other current or former government officials, including former Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Health Chris Fearne. All parties deny the charges. The accusations stem from a 2015 decision by the Maltese government to award a contract for three state hospitals to the then-unknown Vitals Healthcare Group, which later transferred the concession to the American hospital group Steward. Last year, a Malta court annulled the concession, declaring it fraudulent.
Government's Stance
The Maltese government acknowledged Scicluna’s request to ECB President Lagarde, stating, "The Cabinet of Ministers acknowledges Professor Scicluna's decision as being in the best interests of the country." The deputy governor of the Central Bank, Alex Demarco, will take over Scicluna’s responsibilities.
Background and Previous Roles
Scicluna, a former member of the European Parliament and an economics professor, was appointed finance minister in 2013 by then-Prime Minister Joseph Muscat. He assumed the role of central bank governor on January 1, 2021.
Recent Developments
Last Thursday, Prime Minister Abela announced that Scicluna would no longer serve on the Malta Financial Services Authority (MFSA) Board of Directors. Abela referenced the resignations of Chris Fearne and Ronald Mizzi, highlighting the importance of setting the correct example and expressing hope that Scicluna would act in the national interest. Abela mentioned that if Scicluna did not voluntarily step aside, a decision would be made by the Cabinet, which was set to meet the following Tuesday.
Duration of the Legal Proceedings
The duration of the court case against Scicluna remains uncertain, but legal cases in Malta typically extend over several years.
Additional Information:
1. Vitals Healthcare Group Controversy:
- The Vitals Healthcare Group, an unknown entity before receiving the contract, later faced scrutiny for its handling of the hospital concession. This added to the controversy and allegations of fraudulent activities.
2. Steward Health Care Involvement:
- Steward Health Care, which took over the concession from Vitals, has faced challenges and criticism regarding the management and operations of the hospitals involved in the deal.
3. Political Implications:
- The scandal has significant political ramifications, affecting public trust in government officials and leading to heightened scrutiny of government contracts and privatization deals.
4. Impact on Malta’s Financial Sector:
- The suspension of Scicluna, a key figure in Malta's financial sector, may have broader implications for the Central Bank of Malta’s operations and its role in the ECB’s Governing Council.
5. Public and Media Reaction:
- The public and media have been closely monitoring the developments, with widespread calls for transparency and accountability in the handling of the case and the privatization deal.
Vitals Health Details
Overview
Vitals Health, initially known as Vitals Global Healthcare (VGH), was an obscure company before it won a controversial contract to manage three state hospitals in Malta in 2015. The company’s rapid ascent to secure this significant healthcare contract raised numerous questions and concerns about the transparency and legitimacy of the privatization process.
Contract and Privatization
- Awarding of Contract: In 2015, the Maltese government awarded Vitals Global Healthcare a 30-year concession to manage and operate three hospitals: St. Luke's Hospital, Karin Grech Rehabilitation Hospital, and Gozo General Hospital.
- Lack of Experience: At the time of winning the contract, VGH had no proven track record or experience in the healthcare sector, which led to widespread skepticism and allegations of irregularities in the tendering process.
Operations and Management
- Initial Promises: VGH promised substantial investments in the hospitals' infrastructure and improvements in healthcare services. The plans included state-of-the-art medical facilities and enhanced patient care.
- Performance Issues: Over time, VGH faced criticism for failing to deliver on its promises. Reports indicated delays in project completion, substandard quality of work, and financial difficulties.
Transition to Steward Health Care
- Transfer of Concession: In 2018, VGH transferred the concession to Steward Health Care, an American healthcare organization, after facing operational challenges and financial instability.
- Legal and Financial Scrutiny: The transfer raised further questions about the original privatization deal, including the terms of the agreement and the due diligence conducted by the Maltese government.
Legal and Financial Troubles
- Fraud Allegations: Investigations into the privatization deal revealed potential fraudulent activities. It was alleged that the contract was awarded based on manipulated or false information provided by VGH.
- Court Ruling: In 2023, a Malta court annulled the original concession, declaring it fraudulent. The ruling highlighted significant irregularities in the awarding process and the subsequent management of the hospitals.
Key Figures and Accountability
- Involvement of Officials: High-ranking officials, including Edward Scicluna, former Finance Minister, and other senior government members, were implicated in the scandal. They faced accusations of fraud and misappropriation related to the privatization deal.
- Denying Wrongdoing: All accused officials, including Scicluna, have denied any wrongdoing. They have stated that they acted in the best interest of the country and within the legal frameworks of their positions.
Impact and Implications
- Political Fallout: The scandal has had significant political ramifications in Malta, leading to calls for greater transparency and accountability in government contracts and privatizations.
- Healthcare Sector: The controversy has impacted the Maltese healthcare sector, with ongoing debates about the best way to manage public health facilities and ensure quality care for citizens.
- Public Trust: The incident has eroded public trust in government institutions, emphasizing the need for robust anti-corruption measures and transparent governance.
Conclusion
The Vitals Health scandal is a significant episode in Malta’s recent history, underscoring the importance of due diligence, transparency, and accountability in public-private partnerships. The ongoing legal proceedings and their outcomes will likely have long-lasting effects on Malta’s political and healthcare landscapes.
Edward Scicluna's Background
Early Life and Education
- Birth and Early Years: Edward Scicluna was born on October 12, 1946, in Malta.
- Education: He pursued higher education in economics, earning his Bachelor’s degree from the University of Malta. He furthered his studies with a Master’s degree and a Ph.D. in economics from the University of Toronto in Canada.
Academic Career
- Professor of Economics: Scicluna has had a distinguished academic career. He served as a professor of economics at the University of Malta, where he was also the head of the Department of Economics.
- Publications and Research: He has published numerous papers and articles on economics, both in academic journals and the popular press. His research interests include monetary economics, public finance, and economic policy.
Public Service and Advisory Roles
- National Statistics Office: Scicluna served as the Chairman of Malta’s National Statistics Office (NSO), where he oversaw significant improvements in the country’s statistical methodologies and outputs.
- Economic Advisor: He has also been an advisor to several Maltese governments on economic policy, contributing his expertise to various national economic plans and strategies.
Political Career
- Member of the European Parliament: Scicluna was elected as a Member of the European Parliament (MEP) in 2009. During his tenure, he was involved in several key committees, including the Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee.
- Finance Minister: In 2013, he was appointed Malta’s Finance Minister under Prime Minister Joseph Muscat. He held this position until 2020, playing a crucial role in shaping the country’s economic policies and managing its public finances.
Governor of the Central Bank of Malta
- Appointment: Scicluna was appointed Governor of the Central Bank of Malta on January 1, 2021. In this role, he became an automatic member of the European Central Bank’s Governing Council, influencing monetary policy decisions at the European level.
- Responsibilities: As governor, Scicluna was responsible for overseeing Malta’s monetary policy, maintaining financial stability, and ensuring the effective functioning of the country’s banking system.
Contributions and Legacy
- Economic Policy: Scicluna is credited with several economic reforms and policies that have contributed to Malta’s economic growth and stability during his tenure as Finance Minister.
- European Influence: As an MEP and later as a central bank governor, Scicluna has played a role in shaping economic policies not only in Malta but also at the European level.
- Academic Influence: His extensive academic work and publications have influenced economic thought and policy in Malta and beyond.
Personal Life
- Family: Scicluna is married and has children. He is known for his dedication to both his professional roles and his family.
- Interests: Beyond economics, Scicluna has interests in literature, music, and the arts, contributing to a well-rounded personal and professional profile.
Summary
Edward Scicluna’s career spans academia, public service, and politics. His contributions to Malta’s economic policies and his role in the European financial landscape are notable. However, his legacy is currently overshadowed by the ongoing legal issues related to the hospitals privatization scandal. The resolution of these issues will likely shape the final assessment of his career and contributions.
Contact IMEX Malta
